PING · Putters Review

PING Scottsdale Anser Putter Review

The classic Anser blade with the softest insert PING has ever made

By the Tour Issue Golf review desk · Updated November 18, 2026 · Research-based review RECOMMENDED

Excellent

Tour Issue Score 8.7 · Ranked #28 of 38 in Putters

Best for: Slight arc putters who prefer a classic blade shape and want the softest possible impact feel, especially on medium to fast greens

Performance
8.6
Forgiveness
8.2
Feel
9.1
Value
8.7
PING Scottsdale Anser Putter

The Bottom Line

The classic Anser blade with the softest insert PING has ever made. The PING Scottsdale Anser Putter scores 8.7 out of 10 in our research-based review, a excellent mark that puts it at #28 of 38 Putters in our rankings. Its strongest fit: Slight arc putters who prefer a classic blade shape and want the softest possible impact feel, especially on medium to fast greens.

Full Review

The Short Version

The PING Scottsdale Anser is the most familiar shape in golf, rebuilt around a very unfamiliar face. At $197.00 at TGW, down from $257, this 345 gram blade pairs heel and toe weighting and a single back cavity alignment line with a one piece PEBAX insert borrowed from running shoe technology, per GOLF.com. Published reviewers agree on the headline: this is among the softest feeling putters they have tested, and that softness is both the reason to buy it and the reason some golfers should look elsewhere in the Scottsdale family.

Performance

Performance starts with roll consistency. PING says the full face PEBAX insert performs consistently across the face, enhancing speed control, and Golf Digest Hot List testers backed that up, describing end over end roll, tight dispersion and a face that felt even wherever contact was made. GOLF.com explains the engineering trade behind it: the lightweight PEBAX insert creates discretionary weight that PING moves to the perimeter through large face insert cavities, raising MOI and stability for a blade. Golf Monthly found distance control to be a strength, reporting that most putts from outside 30 feet finished within three feet of the hole in its on course testing, with no three putts in that round. That is exactly the job a slight arc Anser with full shaft offset is meant to do for its stroke type.

Forgiveness

No blade will forgive like a high MOI mallet, and the Scottsdale Anser does not pretend otherwise. What it offers is forgiveness within the blade class: heel and toe weighting for stability, perimeter weight saved by the light insert, and a head that Golf Digest testers described as a classic Anser look only slightly bigger, with a touch more help than a traditional blade. The single alignment line in the back cavity keeps aiming simple, per PING. The honest limit, noted by Golf Monthly, is inside 15 feet, where that tester found the flange line encouraged too straight an arc for his stroke and short range consistency suffered. Fit matters here, and PING built the Scottsdale line around its WebFit Putter app for that reason, per GOLF.com.

Feel and Sound

Feel is the story. Golf Monthly called the one piece PEBAX insert one of the softest feeling faces on any putter it has ever tested, and MyGolfSpy coverage of the Scottsdale line described the ball popping off the face despite a soft, muted feel, noting PEBAX is about 20 percent lighter than a comparable TPU insert. Golf Digest testers used words like quiet, plush and soft pop, while also warning that the insert can feel almost too quiet, with limited feedback on longer putts for golfers who judge distance by sound. Golf Monthly added one practical caution: with no grooves on the insert, moisture, sand or dirt between ball and face made feel and roll look a little inconsistent at times. The SuperStroke Tour 2.0 PT grip drew praise from Golf Monthly for a comfortable, balanced hold.

Value

At the $197.00 TGW sale price, value is easy to make. Golf Monthly judged the Scottsdale range competitive at its original $249 to $255 launch pricing against recent competitor releases, so a street price under $200 for the winningest head shape in golf, with a modern insert and a premium SuperStroke grip as standard, is strong. There is no milling story and no exotic material headline beyond PEBAX, but buyers are paying for proven geometry plus a genuinely new feel, not for decoration.

Who Should Buy It

Buy it if you putt with a slight arc, prefer a blade, play mostly on medium to fast greens, and want the softest impact feel in the class. Golf Monthly specifically flagged faster greens as the natural home for this insert. Avoid it if you want a firm, clicky strike, rely on grooves to manage wet or sandy greens, or need mallet level forgiveness on short putts. In those cases a Scottsdale mallet or a milled Anser style putter will suit you better.

Verdict

The Scottsdale Anser earns its score by modernizing a classic without changing what made it a classic. Published testing supports real gains in roll consistency and stability for a blade, wrapped in the softest feel reviewers could recall, and the current TGW price removes the usual premium objection. The deduction is for feel preference and the grooveless face in dirty conditions, not for performance. This is a research-based review.

What We Like

  • One piece PEBAX insert rated among the softest faces Golf Monthly has ever tested, with a muted feel reviewers consistently praised
  • Consistent roll across the face: Golf Digest Hot List testers reported tight dispersion and end over end roll
  • Lightweight insert frees weight for perimeter weighting and higher MOI in a blade, per GOLF.com
  • Distance control strength in Golf Monthly on course testing, with long putts consistently finishing within three feet
  • Strong value at the $197.00 TGW sale price versus a $257 list price, with a SuperStroke Tour 2.0 PT grip as standard

What to Consider

  • Insert is almost too soft and quiet for some golfers: Golf Digest Hot List testers said longer putts gave very little feedback
  • No grooves on the PEBAX face: Golf Monthly found moisture, sand or dirt between ball and face made feel and roll look inconsistent at times
  • Still a blade: forgiveness is good for the class but well short of a high MOI Scottsdale mallet on mishits
  • Flange alignment line did not suit every stroke: Golf Monthly tester found it encouraged too straight an arc and hurt consistency inside 15 feet
  • Soft feel takes adjustment on slow greens, per Golf Monthly, and golfers who prefer a firm click should look elsewhere

Specifications

HeadBlade, 345 grams, heel and toe weighted, 17-4 stainless steel
FaceOne piece PEBAX insert, full face
Stroke and OffsetSlight arc stroke type, full shaft offset, plumbers neck hosel
GripSuperStroke Tour 2.0 PT (PING SPST Tour 2.0 PT)
Lengths34 and 35 inches standard, loft 3 degrees, lie 20 degrees (PING)

Score Breakdown

Performance
8.6
Forgiveness
8.2
Feel
9.1
Value
8.7
Overall
8.7

Scores are research-based, drawn from manufacturer specs, tour adoption, and published independent test data. How we score